SK-II: Is it Worth All the Hype?

English: Actress Cate Blanchett at the 2011 Sy...
Cate Blanchett is the official spokeswoman for SK-II.

Of all the luxury products out there, few have had the longevity (and endorsement of Oscar-winning beauties, like Cate Blanchett) of SK-II.  But do the ingredients – and the scientific research behind the ingredients - measure up to the price of the line, which can cost hundreds of dollars for a single product?

The Main Ingredient: Pitera – A Fermentation Product of Yeast

Under conditions of low oxygenation, anaerobic organisms are able to produce energy via a process known as fermentation.  While many skin care formulations include by-products of fermentation, Pitera is different because it “[...] uses an exclusive yeast while other skincare brands are based on yeast from beer,” according to Takashi Yoshii, senior manager for Global Technical Marketing at the Procter & Gamble Kobe Technical Center.

Unfortunately, with all due respect, little research thus far demonstrates that different sources of yeast make a difference in the quality of fermentative by-products.  (For the record, Pitera is from Saccharomycopsis, which is from the same family as Saccharomyces cerevisiae and uvarum used in beer.)

Fortunately, there is research demonstrating that yeast is an excellent source of peptides, proteins, amino acids, carbohydrates and nucleic acids, as documented in the journal Household and Personal Products Industry.  Although some of these compounds merely hydrate the skin when applied, they are still most likely beneficial for the skin, if for no other reason than moisturization.

There is also limited research, produced by Procter & Gamble (the brand behind SK-II) attesting that the Pitera increases the production of hyaluronan – a component found in the skin’s extracellular matrix – in a synthetic skin model. Since hyaluronan synthesis normally slows with age, this is considered to be a unique way to address the problem of aging.

Does Pitera Work in Other Ways as Well?

Another exciting report from Procter & Gamble is that Pitera (Saccharomycopsis Yeast Ferment Filtrate) reduces production of oxidative species.

Yeast fermentation has been shown to increase the activity of components of the skin known as polygalacturonases.  One common polygalacturonase in skin care is allantoin, which is normally soothing for the skin.  So perhaps Pitera’s soothing properties stem from increased allantoin production.

Use of the Line

From inspection, my favorite product in the line is the SK-II Facial Treatment Essence ($137.99, Amazon.com) which seems to contain the highest concentration of Saccharomycopsis Yeast Ferment Filtrate (Pitera), as well as sodium hyaluronate.

Sodium hyaluronate, often used in place of its hyaluronic acid form for its greater stability in skin care products, acts as a natural moisturizing factor, drawing water into the skin.  This has two immediate effects:  one, it minimizes trans-epidermal water loss (TEWL), and two, it creates a slight swelling of the skin, which reduces the appearance of fine lines and wrinkles a bit.  This means that sodium hyaluronate may have long-term effects as well: according to Dr. Howard Murad, hydration of the skin with NMFs allows the skin to operate at optimum capacity, and provides a better defense against environmental assaults.

Overall Opinions

In short, I like the SK-II line, particularly the SK-II Facial Treatment Essence.  I think that the research suggests yeast extract may be beneficial, and the sodium hyaluronate is proven to beautify and hydrate the skin.

What I wish for: more research (especially if it could be, say, a double-blinded in vivo comparison study validating Pitera’s efficacy), more comparison studies (tell me exactly why I should use this yeast when there are retinoids and antioxidants and peptides like palmitoyl pentapeptide-4 with numerous studies backing them out there!), and a lower price tag.

Of course, as-is, the products look lovely and feel luxurious – and make a wonderful gift for that beauty junkie in your life!  I personally am sticking to my antioxidants/retinoids/niacinamide/super high-SPF ritual until more research on Saccharomycopsis is released, but in the meantime, I don’t see how these products could hurt.  (Unless, of course, you don’t like parabens; SK-II Facial Treatment Essence has methylparaben).

As always, talk to your dermatologist before trying this or any new product.   Product Rating: 8/10 (High concentration of proven effective ingredients: 2.5/3, with a deduction for a relatively small amount of published research for Pitera.  Unique formulation: 3/3.  Value for the money: 1.5/3.  Sunscreen [available in some of the SK-II line, though not the SK-II Facial Treatment Essence]: 1/1).

Ingredients in SK-II Facial Treatment Essence

Water, Saccharomycopsis Ferment Filtrate, Sodium Hyaluronate, Butylene GlycoI, Cellulose Gum, Polysorbate 20, Glycerin, Methylparaben, Sodium

Enhanced by Zemanta

Related Posts

  • 64
    Dear Nicki, I've seen a lot of products with Saccharomyces ferment lysate in them recently.  Does it have any effect? -Linda   Dear Linda, There are some who believe yeast (Saccharomyces) may stimulate DNA repair in the skin.  This is based on the fact yeast contains a sequence of DNA that is necessary for double-strand…
  • 60
    One question I receive a lot from readers is whether or not a skin care product will lay on top of the skin, doing absolutely nothing. (Kind-of like a lousy lover.) It sounds crazy, but it does become possible for skin care ingredients to have little to no benefit for your skin. For instance, if…
  • 54
    Submitted via private message on the FutureDerm.com Facebook page: Hello, could you please give some information how denatured alcohol can be harmful for skin?  From the beautypedia site, I gathered alcohol does more harm to skin than good. -B.S. Dear B.S., I have a lot of respect for Paula Begoun.  Her consumer advocacy has opened doors for a…

by Nicki Zevola

7 thoughts on “SK-II: Is it Worth All the Hype?

  1. Sarah says:

    hey nicki,

    in your article you mentioned allantoin, i was wondering if you could maybe do a “spotlight” on it since it’s so commonly used but there’s not too much info on it. I read in a study that it has free radical savaging properties, but another article claimed it increased H2O2 levels in the skin

  2. Jaxs El Maslouhi says:

    You mentioned palmitoyl pentapeptide-4…can you do an update on this star ingredient with best product(s) mention/spotlight? Thanks for the SK-II review. I’ve been waiting for it! It’d be nice to have the efficacy data to back up the celebrity hype and super high price tag.

  3. Daniella says:

    Hi Nikki – —wondering if you could comment on Dermalogica — they have a Map-15 product that looks good. Thanks.

  4. Pingback: AmorePacific Product Review | FutureDerm.com

  5. Arely says:

    Hello I’m 16 I bought the SKK-II
    I bought the SK-II but Im a lil bit scared since there hasnt been enough info. about this product. Also it was banned in 2006 from the China market due to high amounts of metal. Would it be safe to use?:(
    I

  6. Barbara says:

    What do You mean -:” if u dont like paraben…..”
    It gives u Cancer!!!!!!!!!! How can I ” like” it!!!!!?????

  7. Carmen l says:

    Can SK II essence and mask in lotion be used along with Skincenutical CE? If so, which one should be used first? Thanks

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>