BB and CC Creams War – Round 1

War of the BB and CC Creams - Round 1Some products purchased by me. Some products sent for consideration. All opinions are my own. Affiliate links.

Happy Friday! I’m starting a new series here at FutureDerm! It’s the War of the BB and CC Creams (and we’ll include some tinted moisturizers, too).

First, let me give you a little background on traditional BB Creams, which were first created in Germany. BB Creams should (in general) act as a moisturizer, have high SPF,  work as foundation, work as concealer, have anti-aging properties, have brightening properties, have nourishing properties, and some claim to also prime the skin. Most American BB Creams are often just a tinted moisturizer with SPF, but not high SPF. I’m sometimes ok with a BB cream if the BB Cream is not full coverage (meaning it doesn’t act as foundation or concealer) if it blurs imperfections in the skin. Additionally, traditional BB Creams were only available in 1 or 2 shades. They are now available in a wider range of shades from some brands, such as Missha.

CC Creams are the next big thing. I’m new to CC Creams, but here’s what I know about them. CC Creams are known as either color correcting creams or color control creams. They’re the latest generation of BB creams and were developed in Korea. CC creams are supposed to keep all the same skincare benefits of a BB cream, have additional nourishing ingredients, provide more effective skin coverage that looks natural, rather than like a full face foundation. CC Creams are supposed to have high SPF, better coverage, alleviate uneven skintones, and have a lighter and better texture. They’re usually oil-free, which is great for combination skin.

Last but not least, I’m sure you’re all familiar with tinted moisturizers. Tinted moisturizers usually have SPF, a tint to even out your skintone, moisturize the skin, and some have anti-aging benefits. A few recently have been released that mattify the skin. They’re usually light coverage.

I have three products for this first round. First is Sarah McNamara Miracle Skin Transformer Face SPF 20, which Sephora considers a BB or CC Cream, though it is labeled as neither. I chose the shade Translucent as I thought that Light would be too dark for me. Next is the Supergoop SPF 35 Daily Correct CC Cream, in Light to Medium shade. Finally, I have the Prestige Flawless & Ready BB Cream in shade Light.

War of the BB and CC Creams Swatches

These are the products unblended on the back of my hand.

Sarah McNamara Miracle Skin Transformer Face SPF20 – $48 for 1.7 fl. oz

Ingredients
Active Ingredients: Octinoxate 7.5%, Octyisalate 5%, Oxybenzone 2%, Zinc Oxide .85% Ingredients: Cyclopentasiloxane, Dimethicone Crosspolymer, Dimethicone/Vinyldimethicone Crosspolymore, Dimethiconal, Dimethicone, Dimethicone/Vinyl, Cyclomethicone, Eco-Physalis Angula Extract, Passion Fruit, Saw Palmetto Extract, Tocopherol Acetate, Coenzyme Q 10, Retinol Palmitate, Vitamin K, Vitamin D3, Mica, Phenoxyethanol, Caprylyl Glycol Polyoxyethylene 20 Sorbitanmonooleate (E 433), Polyoxyethylene 20 Sorbitanmonooleate (E 432), Fatt-Acid Esters/Triglycerides, Octyldodecanol, Potassium Sorbate, Aqua, Hexylene Glycol, Glycerin.
*May Contain Titanium Dioxide and Iron Oxides

Claims
A breakthrough 5-in-1 tinted skin enhancer designed to Hydrate, Prime, Enhance, Mattify & Protect your skin in one simple step. This multi-tasking complexion enhancer instantly provides your skin with an antioxidant-rich hydrating base, primed smooth finish, weightless coverage, and SPF20.

  • Reduce the appearance of hyperpigmentation
  • Diminish the appearance of fine lines and wrinkles
  • Minimize the appearance of pore size and uneven skin texture
  • Hydrate to provide long lasting nourishment and anti-aging benefits
  • Help protect against future sun damage with SPF 20.
  • EcoPhysalis – a natural plant extract that helps protect your skin from free radicals and even out the appearance of skintone. From the Brazilian rainforest.
  • M3 Complex – a combination of anti-oxidants and vitamins including Saw Palmetto, Passion Fruit, Vitamin A, Vitamin E and CoEnzymeQ10.
  • Free of synthetic fragrances, dyes, wax, mineral oils, and talc.
  • Cruelty-free policy – We work hard to preserve the integrity of our product line, and as a result, we have a longstanding policy to not test on animals. Also, there are no animal by-products in any ingredient of our Miracle Skin Transformer products. We do not sell in China.

 

Sarah McNamara Miracle Skin Transformer Face SPF20 Shades Available

Shades Available
Translucent (what I purchased)
Light
Medium
Medium Tan
Tan
Dark
Deep Dark

Supergoop SPF 35 Daily Correct CC Cream -$32 for 1.6 fl. oz.

Ingredients
Active Ingredients: Titanium Dioxide 2%, Zinc Oxide 20%; Other ingredients: Water, Cyclopentasiloxane, Propanediol, Dimethicone, Iron Oxides, Lauryl PEG-9, Polydimethylsiloxyethyl Dimethicone Glycerin, Phenoxyethanol, Pyrus Malus (Apple) Fruit Extract, Sodium Chloride, Mica, Dimethicone/PEG-10/15 Crosspolymer, Titanium Dioxide, Triethoxycaprylylsilane, Silica, Dimethicone/Vinyl Dimethicone Crosspolymer Chondrus Crispus Extract, Tetrasodium EDTA, Hydrolyzed Chondrus Crispus Extract Methylisothiazolinone, Tin Oxide, Sodium Hyaluronate.

Claims
A silky formula that covers imperfections in an easy one-step product blended with light-diffusing mica which instantly softens the look of lines, wrinkles and pores – leaving behind a fresh and flawless face. Supergoop! CC Cream combines the functionality of a primer/foundation with the anti-aging benefits of skin serums to protect, correct and smooth uneven skin. Available in self-adjusting shades. The Supergoop! skincare product line delivers three distinct benefits to the skin: superior broad-spectrum sun protection, amazing anti-aging benefits and super antioxidants to help fight free-radical, wrinkle-forming damage. Supergoop! takes seriously its commitment to formulating with healthy ingredients and natural preservative systems: no parabens, fragrances, petrochemicals or oxybenzone to provide an environment- and skin-compatible choice for UV protection.

  • Neutralizes discolorations and blotchiness, restoring vibrancy and glow
  • Promotes youthful skin with anti-aging benefits
  • Protects from UVA, UVB, and IRA (infrared rays) – highest PA+++ rating for highest UVA protection
  • Softens the look of fine lines, wrinkles, and pores
  • Reduces skin inflammation
  • Leaves behind a fresh and flawless face
  • Free of oxybenzone*, parabens, and fragrances
  • 100% mineral active ingredients and antioxidants
  • Mica minerals bind together to create a strong, sheer cream, reflecting light away from creases that seem to instantly disappear
  • Omega-3 and Omega-6 are essential fatty acids that improve skin moisture and overall skin health while reducing inflammation
  • Cruelty-free

 

Supergoop!® 'Daily Correct' CC Cream Broad Spectrum SPF 35 Shades AvailableShades Available
Light to Medium (what I purchased)
Medium to Dark

Prestige Flawless & Ready BB Cream – $11.50 for 1 oz.

Ingredients
ACTIVE INGREDIENTS Octinoxate 7.5% ……… Sunscreen Oxybenzone 2.0 % …. Sunscreen Water/Aqua, Phenyl Trimethicone, Dimethicone, Dicaprylyl Ether, Boron Nitride, Polymethylsilsesquioxane, Silica, Aloe Barbadensis Leaf Juice, Disteardimonium Hectorite, Phenoxyethanol, Dimethicone/PEG-10/15 Crosspolymer, Isododecane, Sodium Chloride, Polyglyceryl-4 Isostearate, Hexyl Laurate, Cetyl PEG/PPG-10/1 Dimethicone, Propylene Carbonate, Dimethicone Crosspolymer, Polyethylene, Polysilicone-11, Ethylhexylglycerin, Aluminum Dimyristate, Triethoxycaprylylsilane, Disodium Stearoyl Glutamate, Disodium EDTA,Citric Acid, Potassium Sorbate, Sodium Benzoate, Sodium Hyaluronate. MAY CONTAIN [+/-]: Mica CI 77019, Titanium Dioxide CI 77891, Iron Oxides CI 77491 / CI 77492 / CI 77499.

Claims
Flawless & Ready Beauty Balm with SPF-15 and Broad Spectrum Protection against UVA & UVB rays.
  • Oil-Free
  • Talc & Paraben Free
  • Cruelty-free

 

Prestige Flawless & Ready BB Cream Shades AvailableShades Available
Light (product sent for consideration)
Medium
BB and CC Creams spread out

Here are the products slightly spread out on my skin. Not blended in.

 

You can tell that Miracle Skin Transformer is very much translucent and works with my skintone. Supergoop CC Cream is dark on me, like a tan. Prestige BB Cream is peachy tan on me.

Sarah McNamara Miracle Skin Transformer in Translucent, Supergoop CC Cream in Light to Medium, and Prestige BB Cream in Light Swatches

Here are the swatched blended out on my hand.

Sarah McNamara Miracle Skin Transformer in Translucent, Supergoop CC Cream in Light to Medium, and Prestige BB Cream in Light Swatches

Another shot of the blended out products.

As you can probably tell from these photos, the Supergoop is way too dark for me. The Prestige is lighter, but still too dark.

Prestige BB Cream Light Unblended

The Prestige BB Cream unblended on my cheek.

 

Prestige BB Cream Light Blended

The Prestige Flawless and Ready BB Cream blended out on my cheek.

The Prestige BB Cream is really more of a tinted moisturizer in my book. I always find it disappointing when a product is named a BB cream and it turns out to be more of a sheer tinted moisturizer. Additionally, shade Light is too dark and peach for my complexion. The SPF is really too low for it to be a proper BB Cream, at 15. I dislike that it contains Oxybenzone. It feels good on my skin but it it’s too sheer to blur any imperfections that I have from my rosacea. I think if you need very light coverage or are not a rosacea sufferer, you will like this product if one of the two shades that available are a match for you.

Supergoop spf 35 daily correct cc cream in Light to Medium

Wearing Light to Medium on my face.

The Supergoop CC Cream definitely offers more coverage. It feels great on the skin as well. You’re still supposed to use this product with one of the other SPF products in the Supergoop line, though this offers the highest PA+++ rating for UVA protection, much like a Korean BB or CC Cream. After wearing it all day (though  I did not submit it to more than 25 minutes in the Florida heat and humidity today because it was so hot), my skin feels very good. It only needed slight blotting on my t-zone. Since I have an oily t-zone, I often expect that I’ll blot at least once a day or be shiny. However, the shade Light to Medium is darker than I ever am, so it doesn’t really work for me. I do think this lives up to its CC Cream name. If either of the shades available in this product match you, I would recommend checking it out.

sarah mcnamara miracle skin transformer spf 20 Translucent swatch

Wearing Miracle Skin Transformer on my skin and nothing else.

The Sarah McNamara Miracle Skin Transformer Face SPF20 in Translucent says it’s a complexion enhancer, and I would agree to that. It’s something I would put on under foundation, though I wore it out on its own one day too. It does blur skin imperfections. It’s hydrating without making your skin oily. Because of all the dimethicone and silicones in it, it feels like a primer and I really think that’s why it’s able to blur imperfections. I wish that the SPF was higher, like 30 or above. One of the things that I don’t like about this product is that it has Oxybenzone. I love that this is available in 7 shades, so there is a good chance that one of the shades will fit you. I didn’t get oily at all with this product, not even on my t-zone. I also sort of feel like it brightened my face a bit when worn by itself. When I wore it out to have lunch with my friend she asked me if I had on a luminizer, and I said no, just one translucent product. She said it gave me a glow in a good way.

For me, Round 1 goes to the Miracle Skin Transformer. While it’s not perfect because it has oxybenzone in it and its SPF is lower than I prefer, I like how it looks and feels on my face. It works well under other foundation products.

Which BB or CC Cream won this War for you?

Related Posts

  • 73
    Products purchased by me. All opinions are my own. Affiliate links. Happy Friday! I'm back with my 2nd Round of the BB and CC Creams War! You can see Round 1 here. I'm fighting with BB Creams, CC Creams and tinted moisturizers to find out which products are best for you. I have three products…
  • 50
    Happy Friday! Today I've got a video tutorial to share with you - the Winter Beauty Trend Metallic Purple Eyes. Metallic eyes are in this winter, especially in shades of purple, red, burgundy, grape, and gunmetal. I chose to use Fyrinnae's new Winter 2013 Snowboarding (see my review of the collection), which is a vibrant…
  • 46
    I'll admit, I'm slow to change:  When BB creams first came out, I didn't like the fact that they only came in 3-5 shades each.  Then, I started to realize that they usually had only silicone bases, meaning that the key ingredients were laying on top of the skin, not embedded in delivery systems absorbed…

by Phyrra

15 thoughts on “BB and CC Creams War – Round 1

  1. Katrina Schenfield says:

    I think the whole BB, CC (and now DD) craze is craziness, and personally I’ll stick with my homemade skin care from real plant extracts. But it’s good to read your honest opinion of these types of products and I love that you tested these out and had so many awesome pics! Thanks!

  2. cinseven13 says:

    Nice that there’s a translucent version out there, but I agree it’d have to be worn under foundation or something else. It just wouldn’t conceal my rosacea.

  3. Natasha says:

    I wish the Supergoop came in a lighter shade… it wins for me, but because it’s too dark, I’m not going to try it. The other two don’t even come close b/c I need an SPF of at least a 30. Revlon’s BB cream is rather nice — has a good texture, range of shades and SPF 30…. the best drugstore BB I’ve tried.

  4. Phyrra says:

    @Natasha
    Supergoop just contacted me asking me to test drive a lighter shade in the Supergoop! It’s definitely a great feeling product and if I had a tan it would work on me. I’m so excited that they saw my post and they’re working on it!

    @Cinseven
    When I wore it out alone to lunch my friend asked what I’d been doing differently with my skin and if I’d been getting facials (which I have), so I felt pretty good about that, but I’m way more comfortable slapping a bit of powder foundation on top of it.

    @Katrina
    You’re very welcome :)

  5. Kiss My Sparkle says:

    I thought the whole CC cream trend was silly until I received a sample of the Supergoop! CC cream, Surprisingly (to me), I <3 <3 <3 LOVE <3 <3 <3 it. I'm currently saving my Birchbox points specifically to get the full size product because it was so fantastic on my skin. I'm glad to hear you liked the formula, too.

  6. Elizabeth says:

    Initially, I was very excited about this category. I started out with Miracle Skin Transformer, which I really liked at first. It gave a finished look on the face and yet it did not look like foundation makeup. After regular use over a month or so, I felt that Miracle Skin Transformer was clogging up my pores. I did not break out, but I did have a lot congested pores and blackheads. Also, I found that after several hours of wear, the color and texture seemed to change on me.

  7. Sandy says:

    Hey Phyrra,
    I have the same porcelain white complexion (lovely) as you do, and the same roseacea (boo!). And I live in Florida, too! My sunscreen of choice as of now is Paula’s Choice Resist, which only has an SPF25, so I’m still looking for a product that is cruelty-free, higher SPF and has some coverage.

    Question: what is it about Oxybenzone that you don’t like? What does it do to the skin that I should avoid?

    Thanks,
    Sandy

  8. Phyrra says:

    @Kiss My Sparkle
    So happy that you love the Supergoop! It’s definitely a great product if it matches your coloring and I love the ingredients.

    @Elizabeth
    I’ve not used it for more than 2 weeks, so I can’t really attest to that. I can say that none of the products above have caused me to break out, nor did I feel like my pores were clogged.

    @Sandy
    I’ve read a lot of material recently that suggests it can cause health issues. Paula’s Choice is cruelty-free, and their Tinted Moisturizer is SPF 30 (I love it ). Supergoop contacted me to ask me to test drive the Light version of their CC cream, so I’m really excited by that! It might work for those of us who are porcelain skinned.

  9. Kris says:

    I’m excited to see your review of the lighter shade of Supergoop. I’ve heard really good things about it, but it doesn’t seem to fit my color either!

  10. Pingback: Winners of the BB & CC Creams War | FutureDerm - Skin Care - Retinol - Beauty Blog

  11. Pingback: BB and CC Creams War - Round 2 | FutureDerm - Skin Care - Retinol - Beauty Blog

  12. Pingback: BB and CC Creams War - Round 3 | FutureDerm - Skin Care - Retinol - Beauty Blog

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>