Olay Age-Defying Eye Cream Ingredient Analysis: Will it Really Reduce Wrinkles?

Skin Care


Wrinkles typically signify a life well-lived, full of memories and unforgettable experiences  – but eye wrinkles are just plain bothersome.  Olay’s new Age-Defying Anti-Wrinkle Eye Cream ($10.98, amazon.com) promises to reduce the appearance of orbital (around the eye) wrinkles using a combination of beta-hydroxy acid, green tea, and retinyl propionate, without all of the pain and hassle of surgery.  If you suffer from crow’s feet, Olay’s new cream may just be the product for you.

Green Tea: Protects Your Skin in Many Ways


Green tea is good for protecting skin from UV and free radical damage.
Green tea is good for protecting skin from UV and free radical damage.

Green tea is good for more than a delicious and relaxing beverage  — it’s actually a sort of miracle herb that has fights against skin cancer formation and free radicals.  What makes green tea so powerful is its polyphenols, molecules that act as very aggressive antioxidants against a spectrum of free radicals, bacteria, and photodamage.

For example, it was found that topically applying a green tea cream  reduced  sunburned cells and DNA damage after UV rays exposure, and even encouraged cell regeneration. Given its sun-protecting properties, several studies have linked topical and ingested green tea to reduced risks of skin cancer. Additionally, green tea’s antioxidant properties allow it to eliminate tumor cells that may be found through the body. However, most studies have been conducted on mice or other animals, and more human subjects are needed (Journal of American Academy of Dermatology).

Aside from UV rays, green tea defends the skin against oxidative stress (damage from the sun, scarring, bacteria) and photoaging. For example, it blocks the enzyme matrix metalloproteinase that is responsible for breaking down your skin’s naturally-made collagen. The less collagen that your skin has, the more that it roughens, sags, and develops wrinkles. Green tea also inhibits lipid peroxidation, a process that diminishes the fat cells that give our skin its plump and smooth texture (Journal of American Academy of Dermatology).

Additionally, Katiyar, Ahmad, and Mukhtar  mention that green tea is a wonderful soothing agent for skin inflammation, especially erythema, and sunburn. While this may seem like a minor benefit, protecting against skin inflammation can prevent some skin diseases and depletion of protective enzymes.

In short, green tea is a great skin-healing agent because it acts as a shield against virtually any attack. It encourages cell regeneration, which means that wrinkles could be partially filled in with newer, healthier cells. Fighting against UV damage, free radicals, and photoaging means that your skin is free to produce the collagen and fat cells that make our skin appear fuller and more youthful and is no longer affected by harmful enzymes like collagenase. Plus, it gets rid of precancerous and tumor cells.

Beta-Hydroxy Acid Help Exfoliate and Deal with the Acne/Fine Lines Dilemma

Beta-hydroxy acids works to  moisturize your skin while gently removing  bacterias. What makes this ingredient so special is that it is oil-soluble so it can easily enter even the most clogged pore — for this reason it’s often recommended by doctors to cure pesky black and white-head pimples. It will also clean up any dead skin cells or excess oils that may be lurking in the depths of your dermis,  preventing future breakouts and revealing the beautiful you (Radiant Skin Clinic).

So what’s Beta-Hydroxy acid going to do for your wrinkles? By exfoliating your skin, there is room for new cells to emerge and theoretically fill the creases caused by wrinkles (University of Maryland Medical Center).

Retinyl Propionate: Smooths Skin, Not So Great for Lines and Wrinkles

Retinyl Propionate helps smooth skin, but doesn't work as well to reduce fine lines and wrinkles.
Retinyl Propionate helps smooth skin, but doesn’t work as well to reduce fine lines and wrinkles.

Retinyl propionate is a form of Retinol, a commonly used skin-healing agent. It’s about 20 times less effective than retinol, which means that while it can help your fine lines and wrinkles, it won’t have the same results as retinol (Journal of Cosmetic Science). Because of it’s pH, retinyl propionate can be used with hydroxy acids without the issues that come along with retinol (Journal of Cosmetic Science).

Research by Fu et al. compared the wrinkle-reducing effects of  niacinamide-peptide-retinyl propionate, and found that the retinyl-propionate cream had much good patient success. Specially, after four weeks patients reported noticeably improved skin smoothness and texture, while 58% of the patients had noticeably reduced wrinkles  after eight weeks.

However, retinyl propionate’s anti-aging effects may be limited. A study on the effects of retinyl propionate on photo-aging (skin damage from sun, scarring, pigmentation issues) found that even after 48 weeks, very few of the 60 patients had noticeably improved skin. The researchers noticed that the length of the study and number of participants may have skewed the cream’s efficacy, and may conduct another study to review their results. It was noted that retinyl propionate did reduce the effects of  actinic keratosis, or excessively dry, painful patches of skin.(Clinical and Experimental Dermatology).

Personal Use and Experience

My mother, Sandy, used this product over a two week period, applying it once in the morning and once in the evening. The cream was very lightweight, dried after only a few minutes, and didn’t leave behind any oily residue. Plus, it had a very faint scent to it, which is good if you use perfumes or scented shampoos. The only drawback to this product is that even if you use small amounts of cream to treat your wrinkles, the bottle will last only for a month before you need to purchase another.

After three days of using the cream, Sandy reported that her wrinkles were visibly smaller and less prominent, and that the skin around her eyes felt smoother and moisturized. After two weeks she still had wrinkles, but they were visibly finer than before and now more easily concealed with foundation. She reported that her skin tone was significantly more uniform afterwards, the wrinkle cream having reduced the appearance of her age spots and mild pigmentation issues.

Bottom Line

After just two week’s time, Olay’s Age-Defying Anti-Wrinkle Eye Cream visibly reduced my mother’s eye wrinkles and minor skin pigmentation issues on her face. A lightweight, scentless, fast-acting cream, Olay’s product provides a cost and time-effective product. Of course, products that have more powerful ingredients in higher concentrations will, undoubtedly, have a great effect. So if you want to really smooth fine lines and wrinkles, consider something like a retinol. But for someone looking to deal with very fine lines or skin they want to smooth, this could be a good product. Aside from skin repair, this cream should also protect against some UV and photaging damage (green tea),  repair its texture (retinyl propionate) and gently exfoliate the skin to allow for new cell growth (beta-hydroxy acid).

Check our bestsellers!

  • Taylor

    Dear Kimberely,

    I found two more articles that may answer your questions about eye creams and retinol. I would just like to reiterate that our FutureDerm retinol is a great product (many of us at the office have used it on our skin and love it) for skin repair, but not around the eye area, given that area’s extreme sensitivity and thinness compared to the rest of our face. I hope that you continue to enjoy our blog, and if there are any more questions please do not hesitate to ask .



  • Taylor

    Hi Kimberly!

    Thanks for replying, and I’m so glad to hear that you are enjoying our blog! I do not recommend that you use our retinol around your eyes, as the skin around our eyes if very sensitive and retinol would likely agitate your skin to some degree and possibly even your eyes . Here are two articles about how our retinol works

    May I ask what is it around your eye are that you are looking to cure? And do you want your product to contain retinol, or be able to get rid of lines or skin damage? If it is fine lines, dispigmentation, scarring or photoaging you may want to give B Kamin’s a try . My mother and I have both used this product and absolutely loved it. https://www.futurederm.com/2013/01/31/will-b-karmins-nia-stem-serum-kx-really-get-rid-of-wrinkles-and-dark-spots/
    Additionally, my mother has been using Olay Regenerist for a few weeks and found that it has been a great multi-purpose agent, from discoloration to wrinkles and skin elasticity.

    I hope that this has answered your questions. If there is anything else that you would like to know or want some more product recommendations, please feel free to comment again or email me at taylor@futurederm.com . Have a great day and I hope you keep enjoying our blog!

  • Kimberly

    I just ordered Future Derm retinol. Will it be good to use around the eyes? I’m new to the blog and haven’t read through all the articles. So I don’t know if the blog recommends a particular eye cream with retinol or whether Future Detm is suitable for eyes or if a separate retinol cream is really necessary for the eye area I’d appreciate a clarification especially if you have a link to a past blog post that addresses my questions. Thank you in advance as I am enjoying this blog very much!

Recent Posts