It’s tempting to try out acne remedies that you can grab in your medicine cabinet. The idea that you could have something here, right now, that would be the miracle cure to treat that just-emerging zit seems ideal. Unfortunately, there are plenty of at-home remedies that don’t work.
I remember the first time I heard about Neosporin for acne. I stood in the mirror staring at a big, red pimple that had just popped up. One of the girls in the bathroom imparted the kind of woman-to-woman knowledge that happens at the restroom sink: “Put Neosporin on that.”
Neosporin is part of a group of infection-preventing creams and gels containing Polymyxin B Sulfate, Bacitracin Zinc, and Neomycin, which are known as Triple Antibiotic Ointments (TAOs). And while these topical ointments work well to prevent infection in wounds, they shouldn’t be used to treat acne. In fact, while they’re very effective for wounds, TAOs can do more harm than good when it comes to treating acne.
Are the Ingredients in Triple Antibiotic Ointments (TAO) Acne-Fighting?
It seems somehow logical that TAOs would work. After all, acne that’s caused by bacteria should be taken care of by a cream intended to kill bacteria, right? Unfortunately, that’s not entirely flawless logic, and not just because Neosporin is intended for wound care and not acne clearing.
Because of the nature of these ointments — intended for temporary wound healing and not regular acne use — applying them too regularly can cause the bacteria they’re intended to kill (and which live on your skin) to become immune to most treatments, which is a big problem later down the road.
Right down to ingredients, it’s evident that TAOs aren’t really acne-friendly. Neosporin contains: Polymyxin B Sulfate, Bacitracin Zinc, Neomycin, Cocoa Butter, Cottonseed Oil, Olive Oil, Sodium Pyruvate, Tocopheryl Acetate (Vitamin E), White Petrolatum; with the first three being the active ingredients.
First and foremost, you might notice that certain ingredients like olive oil can clog pores and actually worsen acne.[Read More: How to Get the Maximum Benefit from Skin Oils]
Here are the bacteria that the three active ingredients are used to kill: Staphylococcus aureus, streptococci including Streptococcus pneumoniae, Escherichia coli, Haemophilus influenzae, Klebsiella/Enterobacter species, Neisseria species, and Pseudomonas aeruginosa (Daily Med).
While it’s possible for many types of bacteria to cause acne, Propionibacterium acnes is the type most commonly responsible for acne vulgaris (European Bioinformatics Institute). This means that from the get-go, we know that Neosporin’s active ingredients aren’t intended to fight the main acne-causing bacteria.
Why the Active Ingredients in Triple Antibiotic Ointments Don’t Work for Acne
Polymyxin B Sulfate
Polymyxin B Sulfate is an antibiotic that’s intended for gram-negative bacteria. These bacteria are commonly what cause infections in wounds and after surgery (CDC). These are often resistant to drugs and, more concerning, are able to adapt to become resistant to antibiotics, which is why you don’t want to use antibiotics for a prolonged period of time or too frequently.
So this ingredient can be ruled out quickly, not only because it can be unsafe to used for a prolonged period but also because Propionibacterium acnes is a gram-positive bacteria.
Bacitracin does work against gram-postitive bacteria, but it really only works against S. aureus and streptococci. It also works as a superficial bacterial infection, meaning that it won’t penetrate the skin enough to really reach the cause of acne (MedScape).
And if you perked up at the mention of zinc because you’ve heard it in acne forums, think again.
Zinc is sometimes discussed in terms of acne because studies have shown that those with acne tend to have lower levels of zinc in their bodies. And while taking zinc has been shown to help to some extent with acne when taken orally, it’s still not as effective as oral antibiotics (NYU Medical). Studies done on topically applied zinc have found that it’s no better than the placebo (International Journal of Dermatology).
Neomycin works by getting in the way of protein synthesis and can be used on gram-positive and gram-negative bacteria. But that doesn’t mean it works against P. acnes either. It’s primarily intended for gram-positive S. aureus, as well as E. coli.
And aside from that, it’s been shown to cause allergic contact dermatitis, as well as nonallergic irritant reactions, in some individuals (Pediatric Consultant Live, JAMA Network). Irritation and contact dermatitis on top of acne is, inevitably, a terrible thing, which makes this a poor choice for acne fighting.[Read More: Acne: What Causes it and What to Do About It]
Why Triple Antibiotic Ointments Might Help Sometimes
There’s a delicate balance with acne and moisturizing and that could explain why triple antibiotic ointments, such as Neosporin, can make your acne seem like it’s improving. Neosporin’s ingredients are intended as a wound-healing aid, which means while they won’t kill acne bacteria, they will help skin to heal.
Moisturizing helps to heal the appearance of scars, and works even better under something occlusive, like petrolatum (International Journal of Cosmetic Science). It can help skin that’s been damaged by acne regain proper barrier function, which makes the acne seem better, but is really the skin around it healing.[Read More: Study Focus: Moisturization is Very Important for Scar and Stretch Mark Repair]
When it comes to acne, it’s best to stick with products that have been proven scientifically and which are recommended by dermatologists. Triple Antibiotic Ointments, such as Neosporin, not only contain pore-clogging ingredients that can exacerbate acne, but they can also cause the bacteria they’re intended to kill to become resistant if applied regularly. While these products are great for preventing infection and wound healing, they shouldn’t be used to treat acne.
Even when home remedies work, it can be more effective to find products that contain them as ingredients. This is because products formulated for your face and for acne are made to minimize irritation and be as effective as possible, whereas complications may arise with the homemade version.
Looking for the best skin care? FutureDerm is committed to having its customers find — and create — the best skin care for their individual skin type, concern, and based on your ingredient preferences. Learn more by visiting the FutureDerm shop!